"Better Than The Movies" by Lynn Painter: A Review
- Amanda Hayes
- Mar 30, 2024
- 12 min read
Love is in the air, and we're swooning over our latest rom-com read! Whether you're a hopeless romantic or simply seeking a delightful escape into the world of love and laughter, our March Busy Bee Book Club's pick of the month is bound to charm you from the very first page. With witty banter, heartwarming moments, and a dash of drama, our chosen rom-com promises to whisk you away on a rollercoaster ride of emotions that will leave you grinning from ear to ear. So, cozy up with a warm blanket and your favorite snacks as we dive into the captivating world of Better Than the Movies.
Better Than the Movies by Lynn Painter
Perpetual daydreamer Liz Buxbaum gave her heart to Michael a long time ago. But her cool, aloof forever crush never really saw her before he moved away. Now that he’s back in town, Liz will do whatever it takes to get on his radar - and maybe snag him as a prom date - even befriend Wes Bennet. The annoyingly attractive next-door neighbor might seem like a prime candidate for romantic-comedy fantasies, but Wes has only been a pain in Liz’s butt since they were kids. Pranks involving frogs and decapitated lawn gnomes do not a potential boyfriend make. Yet, somehow, Wes and Michael are hitting it off, which means Wes is Liz’s in. But as Liz and Wes scheme to get Liz noticed by Michael so she can have her magical prom moment, she’s shocked to discover that she likes being around Wes. And as they continue to grow closer, she must reexamine everything she thought she knew about love - and rethink her own ideas of what happily ever after should look like. |
The Review
Before continuing, please note that the following content warnings apply and could be triggering to certain readers: death of a parent, grief, mental health, vomit, car accident.
SUMMARY - NO SPOILERS
Lynn Painter carves out her own spot in the world of chick lit with her endearing tale of discovering that sometimes the one for you is the one who has always been by your side, rather than the one who catches your eye. In her novel, Painter expertly navigates the enemies-to-lovers trope, infusing it with freshness and authenticity true to the story of Liz and Wes. The brilliant choice to commence each chapter with a quote from a beloved rom-com film adds a charming layer to the narrative, only to break the mold towards the book's conclusion, surprising readers with a twist. Despite its title, Better Than the Movies delivers a rom-com-worthy tale, surpassing the very movies it references. While the story occasionally skims the surface and may make it challenging to fully connect with the characters and their situations, it undeniably encapsulates the essence of the rom-com genre. Brimming with charm, drama, heartache, and laughter, Painter adeptly pays homage to both the rom-com and chick lit genres, making her work a standout highlight of the month.
The Swarm Scores
Horror Score | Settign aside the gnome-decapitation and frog-centric pranks, this book features vomit and a bloody nose, which stand out against the romantic theme. |
Romance Score | The connection between Liz and Wes develops very naturally and their witty banter and presence in each other's lives make the story. |
Tear Score | Featuring the death of a parent, Painter does a beautiful job of exploring how the grief of loss and the way it affects our lives shapes the people we are and how we interact with those around us, especially loved ones. |
Humor Score | While most of the comedic elements of the story come from background characters, they add fun moments of humor and lightheartedness to the story that is both unexpected and humorous. |
Believability Score | In great part, the story falls into the realm of surface-level storytelling with significant pull on the rom-com genre and films to inspire elements of the narrative, yet does manage to stand on its own two feet and carve out a believeable path to romance for the characters. |
Predictability Score | Painter pulls from the rom-com genre and the inspiration derived from the popular films to infuse her story with the magic and joy of rom-coms, but manages to break the mold in the end and tell her own story. |
Fluff Score | With only seventeen chapters, the story is very much to the point, jumping from one imapctful scene to another, however, there are times when the story feels like it plateaus and stalls as there are information dumps. |
The Analysis
The below review will contain spoilers. Do not continue reading this section if you wish to avoid spoilers for the story.
Better Than the Movies is a book that practically begs for its own cinematic adaptation. Despite its title, the narrative unfolds in such a visual and immersive manner that it feels as though you're watching a movie play out before your eyes. Lynn Painter achieves a remarkable balance, seamlessly blending the elements of storytelling and cinematic imagery in her debut work. Painter's writing exudes a delightful combination of fun and down-to-earth charm, making Better Than the Movies an effortless and enjoyable read. It's the kind of book that seamlessly fits into your beach bag, offering the perfect escape for lazy summer days. With each turn of the page, the story unfolds with such fluidity that it's almost as if you're reading subtitles to a movie that's playing in your mind. It's a testament to Painter's skill as a writer that she makes the process of bringing her story to life seem so effortless.
Wes and Liz embark on their enemies-to-lovers journey, surprising everyone with the effortless chemistry that simmers beneath their antagonistic facade. From the moment they step onto the scene, their interactions crackle with both tension and ease, whether in the privacy of their own conversations or under the watchful gaze of others. One particularly memorable instance is when Liz, in a bold move, sets aside their differences to enlist Wes's help in a scheme to win Michael's affections—all over a parking spot. While the significance of the parking spot ultimately proves to be irrelevant, serving merely as a humorous pretext for Wes to be closer to Liz, it adds an amusing layer to their already intriguing dynamic. What sets Painter's narrative apart is her skillful juxtaposition of the enemies-to-lovers trope against the more traditional boy-next-door archetype. This unexpected twist injects the story with a delightful blend of humor and intensity, keeping readers eagerly turning pages as they navigate the rollercoaster ride of Wes and Liz's evolving relationship.
As the title suggests, both Wes and Liz defy the conventional expectations of leading man and lady, grappling with their emotions and navigating the complexities of self-discovery and interpersonal relationships. Liz, whose life has been colored by an obsession with rom-coms and grand romantic gestures, finds herself struggling to muster the confidence to authentically express her feelings to those closest to her. While she often aligns with the archetype of a rom-com heroine, Liz breaks away from this mold in moments of vulnerability, particularly when enduring less-than-ideal situations like being vomited on or taking a basketball to the face. Wes, on the other hand, diverges from the typical portrayal of a leading man, eschewing the overt suaveness and charm typically associated with the role. Instead, his appeal is more subtly conveyed through his actions and interactions with Liz. While Liz perceives him as abrasive and mischievous, to those around him, including Liz's closest confidants, Wes is regarded as universally likable and inherently good-hearted. Yet, even as he defies the conventional expectations of a leading man, Wes remains enigmatic and multifaceted, challenging Liz's perceptions and ultimately reshaping her understanding of love and desire. The evolution of Liz and Wes's relationship serves as a poignant reminder of the unpredictability of attraction and the ways in which our deepest desires can diverge from societal norms and expectations. Their journey underscores the complexity of human connection, showcasing how true fulfillment often lies in embracing authenticity and pursuing genuine emotional intimacy.
Painter introduces a captivating element in her book by incorporating popular quotes from beloved rom-coms at the beginning of each chapter. Drawing inspiration from iconic films such as When Harry Met Sally, 10 Things I Hate About You, and Bridget Jones's Diary, amongst others, she creates a charming homage to both Liz's adoration for these movies and her late mother's fondness for them. This clever inclusion not only adds depth to the narrative but also seamlessly aligns with the overarching theme of the story. The use of these quotes serves as a delightful thread throughout the book, weaving together the worlds of fiction and reality in a seamless tapestry. It's a testament to Painter's ingenuity and attention to detail that these snippets from cinematic classics enhance the reader's experience, offering moments of nostalgia and recognition. Furthermore, Painter masterfully integrates this motif into the narrative itself, culminating in a poignant moment when Liz claims her own happy ending and contributes her own quote at the start of the Epilogue. This full-circle moment not only underscores Liz's personal growth and self-realization but also serves as a poignant reminder of the enduring influence of love, both on and off the screen.
Unfortunately, there were moments in the story where it felt as though the narrative lost its momentum, making it challenging for readers to fully engage with the characters and their predicaments. One instance of this was when Liz endured a series of improbable events, such as being vomited on and then getting hit in the face with a basketball resulting in a bloody nose—both within chapters of each other. While such occurrences aren't unheard of in the genre, they risked straining credibility and detracting from the immersive experience of the story. Moreover, Liz's internal struggles, particularly her self-sabotaging tendencies fueled by grief over her mother's death, presented another stumbling block. Her reluctance to accept Helena as her stepmother, her distancing from Joss, and her near-loss of Wes due to her fixation on living out a rom-com fantasy all showcased her internal turmoil. While these themes added depth to the narrative, they occasionally veered into repetitive territory, resulting in moments of unnecessary padding that slowed the story's pacing. Throughout the middle portion of the story, much time was dedicated to exploring these themes, which, while integral to the overarching storyline, occasionally felt like distractions from the main plot. While these detours didn't detract significantly from the overall narrative, they did introduce moments of stagnation that interrupted the flow of the story. Despite these drawbacks, the overarching storyline remained intact, and the resolution ultimately provided a satisfying conclusion to Liz's journey of self-discovery and growth.
Overall, Lynn Painter's Better Than the Movies proves to be a delightful read that lives up to its title by breaking away from the conventional tropes often found in romantic movies. Seamlessly fitting into our Chic Lit Genre of the Month, Painter's narrative shines as it focuses on Liz and the strong women in her life while delivering a deeply satisfying romance story. Painter skillfully crafts a narrative that resonates with women, placing a strong emphasis on female relationships and empowerment. However, the story transcends gender boundaries, offering a universal appeal that anyone can appreciate if they give it a chance. Just as Michael surprises Liz with his unexpected interest in reading the Bridgerton books in the story, Better Than the Movies surprises readers with its ability to captivate and entertain regardless of gender. With its engaging storyline, relatable characters, and heartfelt themes, Better Than the Movies emerges as a compelling tale that transcends the limitations of its genre. Painter's adept storytelling and fresh approach to romance make it a standout read that is sure to leave a lasting impression on all who pick it up.
The Superlatives
CUTEST COUPLE, HEARTTHROB, AND MOST CHANGED
Liz Buxbaum embodies the quintessential rom-com heroine, brimming with dreams of grand romantic gestures, illusions of true love, and a relentless pursuit of finding "the one." Despite her charming and unique demeanor, Liz stands out in true rom-com fashion, not quite fitting in with those around her in personality, interests, or fashion sense. As one-half of our Cutest Couple, Liz's determination and unwavering resolve shine through, propelling her forward even when her desires lead her down unexpected paths. It's her journey through romantic confusion that renders her truly genuine, allowing readers to empathize with her struggle. Ultimately, Liz undergoes a profound transformation, shedding her initially rigid beliefs about love and relationships. As the recipient of our "Most Changed" distinction, she evolves from an uptight, headstrong individual with rigid notions of love into someone who embraces the complexities of real-life romance, acknowledging that life doesn't always mirror the movies. In the end, Liz emerges victorious, having fought for her own version of a happy ending, proving that sometimes love takes unexpected twists and turns before reaching its rightful destination.
Wes Bennett enters the scene as the unexpected leading man, defying all expectations set by the story's blurb. As Liz aptly observes, Wes is certainly not your typical rom-com hero—at least not initially. However, what readers swiftly come to realize, a truth that Liz herself discovers through a journey marked by heartbreak and scheming, is that Wes is undeniably the one meant for her. With his caring nature, unwavering attention, and instinct to leap into action whenever Liz is in need, Wes embodies the epitome of a man who prioritizes your well-being and security above all else. Bestowed with the title of Heartthrob, Wes's character is one that tugs at the heartstrings of readers, particularly when he reveals his long-held affection for Liz, dating back to their second-grade days. Moments such as these, where Wes's genuine feelings shine through, serve to break the mold of the stereotypical leading man—a portrayal that resonates deeply with the unpredictability of real-life romance. Wes isn't confined to the cookie-cutter archetype that movies often depict; rather, he exemplifies the complexity and depth that make for the most compelling leading men. In Wes, we find a character who challenges convention and reminds us that true love often defies expectations, making him the perfect embodiment of a memorable and authentic leading man.
BEST FRIENDS
Joss is the epitome of the ideal best friend—the kind of friend everyone yearns for, which is why she rightfully earns the second half of our Best Friends superlative. Thoughtful, attentive, and genuinely excited to spend time with her best friend, Joss consistently demonstrates unwavering support for Liz. Despite Liz's tendency to prioritize her own emotional and romantic crises, often leaving Joss hanging, Joss remains understanding, giving Liz the time and space she needs before reaching out again. It's Joss's exceptional level of empathy and trust in Liz that sets their friendship apart from the rest. So when Liz's betrayal hits, it's a devastating blow not only to Joss but also to readers who have come to appreciate the depth of their bond. The palpable sense of betrayal and exploitation that Joss feels resonates deeply with readers who understand just how significant the breach of trust is in their relationship. However, true to the essence of friendship, Joss ultimately finds it within herself to forgive Liz, and the two reconcile their fractured bond. Their journey serves as a poignant reminder of the resilience and enduring strength of true friendship, showcasing the power of forgiveness and understanding in overcoming even the most challenging of betrayals.
LIFE OF THE PARTY
Helena embodies the stepmother many wish for but few actually have the privilege to get. Losing a parent is undoubtedly one of life's most challenging trials, regardless of one's age at the time. For Liz, who was just a child when her world shattered, the pain was compounded by the sense of displacement she felt when her father remarried Helena. The void left by her mother's absence seemed irreplaceable, haunting Liz's every step, yet Helena approached her role with a warmth and understanding that eased Liz's heartache. Despite Liz's initial struggles with feeling her mother replaced, Helena proved to be an unwavering source of support, love, and understanding. She embraced Liz as her own, rejoicing in her milestones and offering a guiding hand through life's trials. Even in moments of tension and discord, Helena's presence brought a sense of levity and joy to the scene. Her down-to-earth nature and genuine affection for Liz shone through in every interaction, turning even the most somber occasions into lighthearted moments. Helena's imperfections and flaws only serve to deepen the bond between her and Liz, showcasing the true essence of unconditional love. Through her warmth, acceptance, and unwavering support, Helena exemplifies the transformative power of familial love, proving that even in the face of loss and adversity, the human heart is capable of healing and finding solace in unexpected places.
CLASS CLOWN
Adam and Noah emerge as the dynamic duo in Wes's life, effortlessly claiming this month's Class Clown distinction with their infectious humor and antics. Their playful banter and interactions with Liz infuse every scene with a delightful sense of levity and joy. It's impossible not to grin at least once whenever they make an appearance, their comedic timing and witty retorts leaving a lasting impression. The camaraderie between Adam, Noah, and Wes adds a layer of depth to their friendship, further enriching the story with their endearing personalities. From their constant bickering to the creation of Liz's unforgettable "Mrs. Potato Head" nickname in the aftermath of the bloody nose incident, their antics never fail to elicit laughter and amusement. As true goofballs at heart, Adam and Noah effortlessly capture readers' hearts, much like Liz herself. Their presence injects a sense of fun and spontaneity into every moment, making them indispensable companions throughout the story. Just like Liz, readers can't help but crave their company, eagerly anticipating their next humorous escapade.
An honorable mention is undoubtedly owed to Michael Young, the figure of Liz's childhood crush and teenage infatuation, whose presence serves as the pivotal catalyst for the entire narrative. Throughout the story, Michael undergoes his own journey of development, albeit in a subtler manner. However, what truly stands out is the evolution of his indifference towards Liz, which gradually transforms into a strategic tool when he finds himself hesitant to pursue his own desires. In a striking parallel to Liz's own actions, Michael's shift from indifference to manipulation reflects the complexities of human emotions and the lengths individuals will go to protect themselves from vulnerability. Liz, in her pursuit of Michael, unwittingly uses Wes as a means to an end, only to realize that her affections were misplaced all along—a realization that mirrors Michael's own journey of self-discovery. Michael's character serves as a poignant reminder of the intricacies of human relationships and the ways in which fear and insecurity can shape our actions.
Memorable Quotes
Page 6
"My inheritance was the knowledge that love is always in the air, always a possibility, and always worth it."
Page 9
“Wes had one of those naughty--boy faces, the kind of face where his dark eyes---surrounded by mile--long thick lashes because life wasn't fair---spoke volumes, even when his mouth said nothing."
Page 37
“The one thing in my favor was that I was kind of a love expert."
Page 89
“I was seriously going to die of embarrassment. For sure. It was, in fact, a thing. My death was imminent."
Page 103
“If it was another guy, I might have just given up and called projectile vomiting a cosmic sign."
Page 108
“If he could help me with Michael, I'd give him The Spot, along with the moon and the stars and possibly a kidney."
Page 158
“Yeah." Sometimes I forgot that not everyone was in my head. "I like mixed metaphors."
The side of his mouth hitched up. "How very rebellious of you, Elizabeth."
Page 212
“Wes Bennett knew what a mess I was underneath it all, and there was a little bit of joy in knowing he saw the real me. Freedom."
Page 239
“Me: You're a sociopath.
Wes: Dare you."
Page 269
“Holy God, Wes Bennett was kind of a catch, wasn't he?"
Page 279
“Why did his take on most things---even when he was mocking me---make me laugh?"
Page 317
“He raised one eyebrow, an unspoken question, and I realized at that moment that I wanted it. I wanted Wes. Michael had been my endgame, but I couldn't bring myself to care about that anymore."
Page 320
“To what, again? What was words? How was talk?"
Page 340
“It seemed to me that because of things like car accidents and lost loves, life and death and broken hearts, we should grab every moment and absolutely devour the good parts."
Page 361
“It's like I'd never seen a rom-com before or something. talk about your comedy of errors."
Page 380
“But news flash: you're not a character in a movie. You can wear jeans sometimes and straighten your hair if you feel like it and curse like a sailor and honestly do whatever you want, and she'd still think you're amazing because you are. I guarantee she would've found you charming as fuck when you were smoking a Swisher in the Secret Area---I know I did. And when you attacked me in my car. Talk about character."
Page 441
“He was an absolute mess, and my fingers itched to touch him."
Page 446
“I fell in love with teasing you in the second grade, when I first discovered that I could turn your cheeks pink with just a word. Then I fell in love with you."
Page 454
“I pulled back and let myself stare at his handsome face, at the person who had always been there for me, even when I hadn't wanted him to be."
Comments